carmenjonze wrote: ↑Fri Sep 09, 2022 7:57 am
I mean, I feel bad for her family members who are mourning her. People who actually knew her.
Same.
But to the rest of us, monarchs are symbolic, by design -- they're supposed to be symbols of absolute power. So IMO, their offices can take it.
Well, first off, the U.S. kind of fought a war in 1776 to settle that issue. (Then there was that little war in 1812.) So we are no longer her subjects. Maybe people in Canada or Australia, or even more complex, the Bahamas, etc. might feel differently.
Secondly, it's now a constitutional monarchy. Any power the monarch has is almost entirely symbolic; they really don't reign anymore (unlike say, Saudi Arabia and its king). They are not the source of power (though they do advise Prime Ministers and others). So this goes both ways. On the one hand, she really wasn't in control of the British Empire when it did some of its worst shit throughout history. But on the other, the monarchy as an institution certainly helped legitimate some of that.
News channels have focused on her relationships to/with American presidents, of course on how Harry & Meghan are making themselves at home as new Americans, our bond during WW II, that sort of thing.
So yeah, I'm not her subject. If she walked into the room, I wouldn't bow to her. I really don't have to refer to her as her Majesty (as I see it). But of course she was a human being, and let me put it this way, not one of the worst on this planet. Of course, it's very easy to be noble and decent and kind when you live in a palace and all your needs are more than adequately met by servants. We have to be real about that;
noblesse oblige is easy when all our needs are met and then some with luxury.
I see folks starting to criticize her and discussing her problematic legacy. Well, I have an opinion about that, but that too is cultural custom, that that stuff can at least wait a short bit of time while her family grieves. Timing aside, she can be criticized like any other person on this planet, and IMHO there's no reason eventually not to discuss that. It's fair. I might not jump in, at least not right away, but I understand the views of folks in places like India, Africa, Ireland, and elsewhere that once were under the Empire where the sun would not (supposedly) set.
Anyway, I do like the Sex Pistols song, and I've caught myself singing it in my head a few times lately.
So it's not like there weren't Britons, who were willing to challenge the monarchy with irreverence from the inside.